Choosing Between the LR3 and LR4: A Comprehensive Comparison
If you’re considering owning a Land Rover, you might find yourself torn between the LR3 and the LR4. Both models have their unique charms, but understanding their differences can help you make an informed decision. The most notable distinction lies in the engine performance. The LR4 boasts a more powerful engine with enhanced horsepower and torque. Additionally, the LR4 comes equipped with advanced technology, improved interior features, and enhanced safety systems, which contribute to its higher cost compared to the LR3. Yet, the LR3 remains an excellent choice, particularly for off-roading enthusiasts.
This overview merely scratches the surface. We’ll delve into more details throughout this article, so stay with us!
LR3 vs LR4: A Quick Comparison
The Land Rover LR3 was produced from 2004 to 2009, while the LR4 was manufactured from 2009 to 2016. Let’s take a closer look at the latest production year for each model to better understand their key differences.
| Features | LR3 (2009 Version) | LR4 (2016 Version) |
| Trim Levels | 2 trims | 4 trims |
| Engine Performance | 4.4-liter V8 engine Horsepower: 300 HP max Torque: 315 lbs max |
3.0-liter supercharged V6 engine Horsepower: 340 HP max Torque: 332 lbs max |
| Fuel Economy & Range (City/Highway/Combined) | EPA Estimated 12 / 17 / 14 MPG Range: 273.60 / 387.60 miles |
EPA Estimated 15 / 19 / 16 MPG Range: 342.00 / 433.20 miles |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | 22.8 gal. | 22.8 gal. |
| Transmission | 6-speed automatic transmission | 8-speed shiftable automatic transmission |
| Technology | Haldex all-wheel drive, Terrain Response system, Smaller brakes than LR4, Electronic parking brake |
Height-adjustable air suspension, Bigger brakes than LR3, Standard stop-start technology |
| Interior | Seating capacity: 5-7 No color options available |
Seating capacity: 5-7 4 color options available, Enhanced interior features |
| Safety | Less updated safety features | More updated safety features |
| Warranty Features | Basic warranty: 4 years Corrosion perforation warranty: 6 years Maintenance Warranty: 6 months Powertrain / Drivetrain warranty: 4 years Roadside assistance coverage: 4 years |
Basic warranty: 4 years Corrosion perforation warranty: 6 years Powertrain / Drivetrain warranty: 4 years Roadside assistance coverage: 4 years |
| Price | New: Starting at $45,975 Used: $3,900 – $15,066 |
New: Starting at $50,900 Used: $19,896 – $40,965 |
LR3 vs LR4: An In-Depth Analysis
Let’s explore the differences in detail, analyzing each feature of the LR3 versus LR4.
Engine Performance
The 2016 LR4 comes equipped with a robust 3.0-liter supercharged V6 engine, delivering around 340 horsepower and 332 lb-ft of torque. In contrast, the LR3 typically features a 4.4-liter V8 engine, which maxes out at 300 horsepower and 315 lb-ft of torque. Thus, the LR4 stands out with its superior engine performance and offers more trim options compared to the LR3. However, it’s worth noting that some users have reported supercharged engine issues with Land Rovers.
Winner: LR4
Fuel Economy and Tank Capacity
The LR3 exhibits lower fuel efficiency compared to the LR4, but both models share an identical fuel tank capacity of 22.8 gallons. The LR3 offers a driving range of approximately 273 to 387 miles, while the LR4 extends its range to about 342 to 433 miles. Consequently, drivers of the LR4 can expect to make fewer fuel stops.
Winner: LR4
Transmission
The 2016 LR4 features a standard 8-speed automatic transmission across all its trims, whereas the 2009 LR3 is equipped with a 6-speed automatic transmission. The 8-speed system offers smoother acceleration and a wider range of gear ratios, providing better adaptability for diverse driving conditions.
Winner: LR4
Technology
Land Rover made significant advancements in technology from the LR3 to the LR4. The LR3 includes basic technology such as a standard radio with a CD player, power-adjustable front seats, and dual-zone climate control. In contrast, the LR4 boasts an upgraded infotainment system, a larger touchscreen display, enhanced brake systems, and features like keyless entry and ignition, a power-operated tailgate, and a more sophisticated terrain response system. Standard stop-start technology is also included in the LR4.
Winner: LR4
Interior & Ride Quality
When it comes to interior design, the LR4 showcases substantial upgrades, presenting a more modern and elegant appearance. Both models have seating for 5 with an optional third row. While the LR3 features premium materials like leather upholstery and wood or metallic accents, it only offers one color option. In contrast, the LR4’s cabin is adorned with soft-touch surfaces and premium leather, reflecting Land Rover’s attention to detail. Though LR3 excels in off-road ride quality, LR4 provides superior traction and comfort for on-road journeys.
Winner: Tie
Safety
The LR3 is equipped with basic safety features common for its era, including antilock brakes, stability control, traction control, and multiple airbags. On the other hand, the LR4 includes advanced safety technologies such as Adaptive Cruise Control, Blind Spot Monitoring, and Lane Departure Warning, significantly enhancing driver safety. However, some users have experienced issues with Land Rover’s SOS functionality.
Winner: LR4
Warranty Features
Both the LR3 and LR4 come with reliable warranty options that provide peace of mind to owners. Below are the warranty details for each model:
| Warranty (LR3 2009) | Condition |
| Basic warranty | 48 months / 50,000 miles |
| Corrosion perforation warranty | 72 months / Unlimited distance |
| Maintenance warranty | 6 months / 7,500 miles |
| Powertrain / Drivetrain warranty | 48 months / 50,000 miles |
| Roadside assistance coverage | 48 months / 50,000 miles |
| Warranty (LR4 2016) | Condition |
| Basic warranty | 48 months / 50,000 miles |
| Corrosion perforation warranty | 72 months / Unlimited distance |
| Powertrain / Drivetrain warranty | 48 months / 50,000 miles |
| Roadside assistance coverage | 48 months / 50,000 miles |
Winner: Tie
Price
The used Land Rover LR3 is priced between $3,900 and $15,066, while the used LR4 ranges from $19,896 to $40,965. For new models, the LR3 starts at $45,975, and the LR4 begins at $50,900 MSRP. The LR3 presents a more budget-friendly option for those seeking a luxury SUV, while the LR4 justifies its higher price with an array of upgrades and modern features.
Final Verdict
In conclusion, choosing between the LR3 and LR4 ultimately leads to an excellent SUV experience regardless of your selection. The LR3 offers solid performance, decent technology, safety features, and off-roading capabilities at a competitive price. In contrast, the LR4 enhances all these aspects with superior engine performance, advanced safety, and modern technology, albeit at a higher cost. Both models demonstrate commendable reliability, ensuring you won’t regret your choice.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Does the LR4 Have an Air Suspension System?
Yes, the LR4 features an adjustable air suspension system that allows drivers to manually change the vehicle’s ride height. This functionality enhances off-road performance by providing increased ground clearance for navigating challenging terrains while also improving on-road comfort.
Does the LR4 Have a Surround Camera System?
Indeed, the LR4 is equipped with a surround camera system, one of the first in its class. This system utilizes multiple strategically placed cameras around the vehicle to offer a 360-degree view, aiding drivers in parking, navigating tight spaces, and enhancing off-road visibility.
Does the LR3 Have Hill Descent Control?
Yes, the LR3 includes hill descent control, which allows for a controlled and steady descent down steep slopes without the need for constant braking by the driver. This feature significantly improves safety and instills confidence when traversing challenging terrains.
Endnote
We hope this comprehensive comparison of the LR3 and LR4 helps clarify your decision-making process. Whichever model you choose, rest assured that you are in for a rewarding driving experience. Happy driving!